Freedom Shouldn’t Cost This Much: How Our Tax System Fails Independent Workers

Every April, while most Americans file their taxes with a single W-2 and a sigh of relief, independent contractors navigate a far more complex and punishing process. They weed through spreadsheets, sort receipts, decode deductions, and pray they didn’t miscalculate their quarterly payments—again.

For years, I was one of them. I know the weight of that burden. Today, I lead FLEX Partners, a fast-growing consulting firm powered by a network of some of the most talented, creative, and driven independent professionals in the country. Designers, writers, strategists, marketers, developers—these are the people who help bring our clients’ missions to life. My business – and millions across the nation – couldn’t run without them.

And yet, the system continues to treat them like second-class professionals.

Nearly 36% of the American workforce identifies as freelance or independent. These are people who have chosen a different path—not because they’re unemployable, but because they value flexibility. Because they’re raising families, caring for loved ones, avoiding burnout, or pursuing passions that don’t fit neatly into a 9-to-5. They are America’s workforce of the future—and our tax system is still stuck in the 1950s.

Consider the self-employment tax. On paper, it’s 15.3%. In reality, it’s so much more. It’s tax software, bookkeeping apps, hours of admin work, and often hiring a CPA just to stay compliant – an uncompensated burden on top of client work.

And if they miscalculate? The IRS adds insult to injury with penalties for underpaying quarterly taxes. Imagine working overtime to land a big contract in Q3—only to get punished in Q4 because you couldn’t predict the windfall back in April. Can they write off the crystal ball they needed to see it coming?

Deductions help—but they come with strings attached. The more expenses you claim, the higher your odds of being audited. And without a full finance department or the budget to outsource meticulous recordkeeping, most independent contractors are just hoping they filled out the right form the right way on the right platform. It shouldn’t feel like a yearly dice roll.

And the problems don’t stop at the IRS. Independent contractors are often discriminated against in lending. Try applying for a mortgage or car loan with 1099 income. Even those earning six figures can be told they’re “too risky” because their income doesn’t come with a payroll stub.

Independent contractors don’t want handouts. They’re not asking to pay less. They’re asking for a system that makes sense. A system that recognizes how the American workforce has evolved. A system that doesn’t penalize growth, independence, or autonomy.

They aren’t trying to break the rules—they’re just trying to build something meaningful.

This Tax Day, let’s remember that millions of people didn’t “fall into” independent work. They chose it. Our tax code, lending standards, and financial systems should stop treating them like the exception—and start designing for the reality.

Freedom shouldn’t cost this much.

‍